Share your work for peer review
Send a reviewer a private link, collect their comments on exact passages, and pass feedback to the assistant.
Updated
Peer review lets you share a project with a beta reader, editor, colleague or client. They open a link in their browser, read your chapters and leave comments on specific passages. They don't need a ScribbleIt account, and they can't edit anything.
Create a review link
- Open the project page (click the project name on the Projects page or at the top of the Explorer).
- Click Share for review at the top right.
- In Share for peer review, type the Reviewer's name. This name is filled in for them and shown on their comments.
- Click Create 30-day link.
- The link is created and copied for you ("Review link created and copied."). Paste it into an email or message to your reviewer.
Create a separate link for each reviewer, so you can tell their comments apart and turn off one person's access without affecting anyone else.
Anyone with the link can read and comment, so only send it to people you trust with your draft.
Choose what reviewers see
Reviewers see every chapter, and the sections under it, unless you hide it.
- On the project page, find the chapter in the Chapters list.
- Click the In review button next to it. It changes to Hidden from review.
- Click it again to share the chapter again.
When a chapter is hidden, its sections are hidden too. Archived chapters and sections are never shown.
Reviewers can also see the project's reference documents. Outline files and your style and template examples aren't shared.
Manage your links
Open Share for review again to see Active links. For each link you can:
- Click Copy to copy it again.
- See when it expires.
- Click Revoke to turn it off immediately.
What your reviewer does
When your reviewer opens the link, they see:
- Review materials on the left, with a Find a document... search box.
- The document they're reading in the middle.
- Your review on the right, listing their comments.
To comment, they select text, click Comment, check Your name, type in Your comment and click Send comment. They can delete their own comments.
Read and act on comments
When a document has review comments:
- A comment count badge appears next to it in the Explorer.
- A Review comments button appears at the top of the editor. Click it to open the Peer review panel.
In the Peer review panel:
- Switch between Active and Dismissed comments.
- Use the reviewer dropdown to see All reviewers or just one person.
- Click a comment to jump to and highlight the passage it refers to.
- Choose what to do with it:
- Send to agent: adds the passage and the comment to your chat message box, so you can ask the assistant to address it. Switch to Edit mode if you want the assistant to change the document.
- Applied: mark it as done once you've made the change.
- Dismiss: set it aside. You can bring it back later from the Dismissed view with Restore comment.
Tip: passages with an open comment are protected while you review. If you try to type in one and see "This passage is locked while the comment is open", click the lock icon on the passage to unlock it.
Troubleshooting
- The Create 30-day link button is greyed out. Type the reviewer's name first.
- "The surrounding text has changed." You've edited that passage since the comment was left. Read the comment and find the new wording yourself.
- My reviewer says the link doesn't work. It may have expired (links last 30 days) or been revoked. Create a new link and send it again.
- A reviewer can see a chapter I wanted to keep private. Click In review next to that chapter on the project page so it shows Hidden from review.
- "The link could not be copied." Select the link text in the box and copy it manually.